Connect with us

Domestic policy

Why there are so many problems with the Armenia-Azerbaijan ‘new-old border’

Avatar

Published

on

The trilateral agreement signed by Armenia, Azerbaijan and Russia stopped the war in Karabakh on November 10, 2020 and drew the general outlines of a future peace treaty.

However, both sides immediately began to interpret the text of the statement in their own way.

  • Op-ed: why Azerbaijan needs the deployment of Turkish troops in Karabakh
  • Op-ed: the Georgian-Abkhaz conflict through the prism of the second Karabakh war
  • Armenian opposition: country needs one more Russian military base

The main dispute has erupted around the question: where is the border between Azerbaijan and Armenia? The solution to another important problem depends on the answer to this question: to which borders should Armenia now withdraw its troops?

The problem of the state border between Azerbaijan and Armenia has turned out to be quite complicated due to several problems, primarily related to history.

Let’s analyse each one.

History of the Karabakh conflict

After the first Karabakh war (1989-1994), seven regions of Azerbaijan around Nagorno-Karabakh came under the control of Armenian forces. For the next 30 years, the border between Armenia and the unrecognised Nagorno-Karabakh Republic was conditional, and checkpoints were established quite arbitrarily.

Borders between republics in the Soviet Union were drawn based on the borders of the Russian Empire

Within the Soviet Union, administrative boundaries were never constant. The boundaries of the subjects of the USSR, that is, the union republics, were mainly drawn on the basis of the boundaries of the provinces and counties of the Russian Empire. And how they were drawn, perhaps only God and the Russian Tsar knew.

After the split of the empire, several states were formed on its ruins that declared their independence, including Georgia, Armenia and Azerbaijan.

1980s map.

From the very first day, all three countries began presenting territorial claims against one another, because the old borders of the imperial districts of the 19th century did not take into account the ethnic composition of the population.

In particular, Azerbaijan and Armenia argued over three regions: Nakhichevan, Zangezur and Karabakh.

After the intervention of the Red Army in 1920-21, all the countries of the South Caucasus returned to Russia again, but under a new ‘brand’ – the USSR. And the territorial disputes were quickly and in their own way resolved by the Bolsheviks.

Nakhichevan and Karabakh went to Azerbaijan as autonomous republics.

The Zangezur district of the former Elizavetpol (Ganja) province was divided between Armenia and Azerbaijan. The eastern part became part of Azerbaijan. And Western Zangezur, with a predominantly Armenian population, after a tough armed struggle, became part of Armenia.

But the problems didn’t end there.

Formal and non-permanent administrative boundaries in the USSR

Administrative boundaries between the subjects of the Soviet Union were largely formal. Often, Moscow, in its own way, acting with political or economic considerations in mind, created new union republics or abolished old ones, changed the borders between them, raised or lowered the status of autonomous areas.

This happened with Abkhazia, which initially received the status of a union republic, and then was changed to the status of an autonomous republic within the Georgian union republic.

And Crimea was transferred from the Russian Union Republic to the Ukrainian one.

The exchange of territories between neighboring Union republics was carried out simply, since in Moscow they thought: “What’s the difference if the country is one and the same?”

Such a correction of the administrative boundary between Azerbaijan and Armenia was carried out three times: in 1929, 1935 and 1984.

This was justified by the desire to “optimize” agricultural management.

After the creation of collective farms in the USSR, it sometimes turned out that the village was on the territory of Armenia, and the lands cultivated by the peasants were on the territory of Azerbaijan. And vice versa.

This is how the enclaves of Artsvashen / Bashkend, Voskepar / Askipara, Kyarki / Tigranashen appeared.

The territories of the Gazakh region were transferred to Armenia, the territories of the Goris region – to Azerbaijan.

How do Azerbaijan and Armenia propose to get out of this multilevel problem?

Azerbaijani and Armenian soldiers in their new posts after the second Karabakh war. There are several tens of meters between them.

Baku – return to maps of the Soviet period

Now, after Azerbaijan has regained control over these areas according to the military results of the war and a tripartite statement, Baku insists that Armenian troops should withdraw to the borders of 1988 – that is, return to the administrative border between the Armenian and Azerbaijani republics within the Soviet Union.

Yerevan – take into account new realities and investments made in the development of districts

Armenia claims that over the past years, villages have expanded, new roads have been built, and the development of minerals has begun. Yerevan proposes these new realities be taken into account.

Russia has not offered solutions yet

So far, it seems that the third party, Russia, turned out to be somewhat unprepared for this turn of events. The November 10 statement said nothing about the state border.

Both sides, together with Russian peacekeepers, are trying, using old Soviet topographic maps and GPS devices, to mark on the ground the “old” border between Armenia and Azerbaijan, which should become the “new” one in the future and be officially recognised by the two independent states.

But this process requires clarifications and changes, and is accompanied by many excesses. In particular, one of the Armenian villages will actually be divided in half.

Similar situations with the Azerbaijani-Russian and Azerbaijani-Georgian borders

Several years ago there were similar problems on the Azerbaijani-Russian border.

Two villages were administratively on the Azerbaijani side of the border, but were subordinate to the Dagestan state farm.

In 2010, Azerbaijan and Russia completed the process of border delimitation and both villages remained in Azerbaijan.

But with Georgia, Azerbaijan is still unable to complete the delimitation process. The main controversy surrounding the monastery complex David Gareji / Keshikchidag.

Will an ancient monastery complex in the mountains bring tension between Azerbaijan and Georgia to a head?

Why can the two countries not come to an agreement about the border and solve the problem of David Gareji / Keshishdag?

Continue Reading

AIC

EU regulator to clear Boeing 737 MAX flights next week

Avatar

Published

on

The European Union Aviation Safety Agency (EASA) plans to clear the Boeing 737 MAX to fly again next week, 22 months after the plane was grounded following two fatal crashes.

"For us, the MAX will be able to fly again starting next week," after the publication of a directive, EASA director Patrick Ky said in a video conference.

"We have reached the point where our four main demands have been fulfilled," Ky said during the conference, organized by the German association of aviation journalists.

The MAX was grounded in March 2019 after two crashes that killed 346 people — the 2018 Lion Air disaster in Indonesia and an Ethiopian Airlines crash the following year.

Investigators said the leading cause of both crashes was a faulty flight handling system known as the Maneuvering Characteristics Augmentation System or MCAS.

Meant to keep the plane from stalling as it ascends, the automated system instead of forced the plane's nose downward.

The findings plunged Boeing into crisis, with more than 650 orders for the 737 MAX canceled since last year.

Subscribe to our Linkedin page

Continue Reading

AIC

Simpsons screenwriter passes away

Avatar

Published

on

Producer David Richardson, one of the screenwriters of the animated series The Simpsons, has died at the age of 65, Report states, referring to Deadline magazine.

He passed away because of heart failure. Richardson's family plans to hold the funeral closed to the public. A mass farewell will be held after a while.

Richardson is the author of several television comedies.

Subscribe to our Facebook page

Continue Reading

AIC

Milli Majlis MPs to visit liberated lands

Avatar

Published

on

Milli Majlis's deputies will get acquainted with the situation in the liberated lands and discuss important issues for the development of the agricultural sector in those territories, Report informs, citing the Parliamentary Committee's working plan.

Moreover, the work plan includes issues of visiting families of martyrs by committee members, holding meetings with veterans and participants of the war.

Subscribe to our Facebook page

Continue Reading

Facebook

Trending